Old Fashioned Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Cookies

16.1K

Buttery soft, old-fashioned vanilla oatmeal cookies that melt in your mouth! Simply spiced with a little nutmeg, these are just like grandma used to make… but better.

Old Fashioned Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Cookies - Buttery soft, old-fashioned vanilla oatmeal cookies that melt in your mouth! Thecomfortofcooking.com

Sometimes, the simplest recipe can be the hardest to find. That’s why, today I decided to help you solve your longtime search for the ultimate old-fashioned oatmeal cookie. You know the one, flat and buttery, with crisp edges and a soft, chewy texture. And that vanilla aroma as they bake! Oh, the right oatmeal cookie is just so good.

I’ve baked dozens of batches of oatmeal cookies, but no more than I have in the past few weeks. I had a couple close successes, a few failures, and then I pulled these out of the oven, and the clouds parted. I wasted no time grabbing a glass of milk and plucking one hot off the pan. And then another one.

Even my meh-about-oatmeal hubby couldn’t resist a short stack of these scrumptious cookies! 

Old Fashioned Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Cookies - Buttery soft, old-fashioned vanilla oatmeal cookies that melt in your mouth! Thecomfortofcooking.com

Oatmeal cookies combine all the classic goodness of every good cookie in the world – the buttery indulgence of a chocolate chip and the spiciness of a snickerdoodle. Those are the best cookies in the world according to my household, at least! There is just nothing not to love about an warm, home-baked oatmeal cookie. The perfect throwback treat when you need a comforting sweet!

My little cookie monster is crawling around and getting into mischief, so I’ve got to cut this short. But, trust me, these are the best oatmeal cookies you will EVER bake. They’re so irresistible and delicious and – oh geez, she’s going for my dirty sneakers.

Bake a batch and I promise these will be one of your go-to cookie recipes for all time!

Old Fashioned Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Cookies - Buttery soft, old-fashioned vanilla oatmeal cookies that melt in your mouth! Thecomfortofcooking.com
Old Fashioned Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Cookies - Buttery soft, old-fashioned vanilla oatmeal cookies that melt in your mouth! Thecomfortofcooking.com

5 from 1 vote

Old Fashioned Chewy Oatmeal Cookies

Ingredients

  • 1 cup 2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup packed brown sugar
  • 1 large egg
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 2/3 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1/8 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/8 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 1 1/2 cups quick cooking oats

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line 2 large baking sheets with parchment paper; set aside.
  • In a large bowl with an electric mixer, beat butter and both sugars until fluffy. Mix in egg and vanilla until well blended. Combine flour, cinnamon, baking soda, salt, baking powder and nutmeg in a bowl. Stir into butter mixture. Gently stir in oats until well blended.
  • Shape dough into rounded golfball-sized balls (about 2 Tbsp. each). Place on prepared baking sheet (I fit 9 per sheet). Flatten with the bottom of a measuring cup dipped in sugar.
  • Bake for 8-10 minutes. Let cool on baking sheet 5 minutes before removing to a wire rack to cool completely.
  • Enjoy!

Join the Conversation

  1. These cookies look so perfect! Love oatmeal cookies with a glass of milk :)

  2. I’ve been looking for a recipe like this for what feels like ages! Oatmeal cookies are my absolute favorites and I love how yours are thin yet with a soft and chewy centre. Can’t wait to try them out!

    xo, Elisa

  3. I could eat these cookies every day! YUM!

  4. Mmmm oatmeal cookies are my favourites! I love your little nifty cookie rack as well :) Purdy! Thanks for the recipe :) x

  5. I can always justify eating an oatmeal cookie because they just seem so healthy – even if there are better choices :) These look delicious Georgia!

  6. mmmm I love classics like this!

  7. I truly think soft and chewy oatmeal cookies are my favorite cookies in the world. There’s just nothing like biting into one warm from the oven! Or dipping one in milk. Or sandwiching ice cream between two of them. Or…. that’s it. I have to make these now.

  8. Classic oatmeal cookies are one of my favs! I love your recipe…they look perfectly chewy.

  9. Buttery oatmeal cookies are the best!

  10. I’ve never made an oatmeal cookie without raisins in it. Yours look so perfect – I need to try this recipe.

  11. Just made these! I did 1 1/4 cups of butter and 1/2 a cup of coconut oil…so. good.

  12. My bad…I doubled the butter recipe. Can’t believe I noticed this AFTER I posted that comment. I am going to try the CORRECT recipe this afternoon…wow what a blonde moment I just had! Forgive me!

  13. Yikes! I know you’ll love them with the right butter measurements! ;) Let me know how they turn out for you.

  14. I baked these cookies tonight. They are excellent!!! I made smaller cookies using a Tbsp. cookie scoop… they were the perfect size! I was wondering if there are any suggestions on cutting the sugar in this recipe and still have them taste good? I know it sounds crazy, but I want to make them for my dad, who can’t have a lot of sugar. Thank you in advance for any thoughts and thanks for a great tasting cookie recipe :)

  15. I made these cookies today and they are wonderful! The first bite took me back to when I was a little girl and my mom would make oatmeal cookies. Thanks so much for this recipe!

  16. I’m glad you enjoyed my favourite Oatmeal Cookie. This has been a family favourite for many years.
    ~Ann

  17. Just made these cookies tonight and they are fantastic! I resisted the urge to double the recipe and made 2 separate batches.
    I don’t think they will last till Christmas. But I am going to try to hide them away. They are really amazing. Just wondering if you have any ideas for storage to keep them soft and fresh till Christmas? Someone told me to put in Tupperware and add a slice of bread….any thoughts? Thank you again – I am so happy to have stumbled upon your recipe :)

  18. I was wondering how old fashion oats would work? That’s what I keep in the house.
    They sound so ooo yum!!

  19. Old fashioned oats should work fine. Enjoy!

  20. I add a piece of bread once they start going a little hard and it softens them everytime!

  21. Freeze them! I do it all the time!

  22. I tried these cookies out today for the first time and they are SO DELICIOUS! I’ve made a couple of oatmeal cookies before and so far this is the best one yet. I love the chewy texture and the taste is simple being plain bu the nutmeg and cinnamon just take it to another level. Definitely going to make these again and they are incredibly easy to make :D

  23. Can you add raisins or chocolate chips to this recipe without messing the cookies up? Thanks

  24. Yes, that should work fine. Enjoy!

  25. Thank you Thank you i have found THE best oatmeal cookie recipe without raisins lol. My husband hated oatmeal cookies till i fixed these now both my son and husband fight over them. They come out perfect everytime!

  26. Tried this recipe on Friday, they turned out amazing! Will definitely be my go to for oatmeal cookies. A friend said they taste a little like a snicker doodle. Which is always good. Lol

  27. These are great, they turned out perfect when we made them. Thanks for posting.

    Simon

  28. albertagirl says:

    I don’t know if something went wrong… but I made 2 batches back to back (my first try w/this recipe)..
    I didn’t find them as chewy as I like an oatmeal cookie to be as I am so picky and like them with quite a chew, crunchy edges etc..
    I found these more ‘cakey’ than chewy. I tried forming them differently & cooking time with each 6 cookies and it never really changed my mind.
    The taste itself was quite good, I added cranberry’s in one batch and the other I split in half and put some skor caramel chips in them to see if that would enhance the chew factor, not really, but they tasted even better! lol I would make this one again if I was looking for an oatmeal cookie to mix w/coconut tho.
    All in all for my personal pickiness I’d give 3/12 of 5
    My family ate them to gone in 2 days :)

  29. Can I use old fashioned oats instead of instant? I bought this big box from Costco and am trying to find yummy ways to use it.

  30. I’m not sure what I did wrong but I followed the recipe to the tee except I didn’t have quick oats I had old fashioned. They are greasy and flat. What happened.

  31. Angella Walker says:

    Hi i made these cookies and they tasted great except they werent chewy. What do you suggest i do to get them chewy?

  32. Great Recipe But it seemed a bit lacking in the oatmeal department so i added an extra cup of oats and they still came out wonderful :D

  33. Jough Blough says:

    I made these tonight, and as soon as I opened the oven to take them out and the aroma hit my nose, I knew they’d be amazing! I did 1.5 batch and they’re wonderful. Just the right amount of crispness and chewiness.

  34. I just took the first batch out! Great! Love them flat and chewy. I didn’t have quick oats so I used old fashioned. Really doesn’t seem to make any difference. I’ll do these again.

  35. Yes, the original recipe as printed in the Toronto Star back in the early 80’s uses old fashion oats. It is what I use to make these cookies.

    ~Ann

  36. Just wonder if you sifted the flour a few times before measuring it? Sounds like you may have added too much flour. Just an idea.

  37. Mookie Blaylock says:

    These are delicious. Made them according to your recipe. Thank you for sharing.

  38. Wow, I used this recipe today and only added alittle ginger and clove. (Only because I add them to just about everything we eat.) Oh and about a cup of chocolate chips. And wow! Is all I can say.Great job! You have made the Porter Family Favorites :)
    Thank you.

  39. So super yummy. My whole family loved these cookies. So glad we found them.

  40. These are good! I used vegetable oil instead of butter, flattened 2.5 tbsp to the size of my palm, and they spread quite thin, but were nice and chewy and had lacy brown edges. Next time I’ll flatten them less.

  41. wonderfuⅼ put up, very informative. I ponder why the otheг exрerts of this sector don’t realize this.
    You must continue your writing. I am sure, you hɑve a huge readers’ base alreɑdy!

  42. Hello my friend! I wish to say that this article is amazing, nice written and include almost all important infos. I’d like to see more posts like this.

  43. 5 stars
    I added coconut and pecans and they were delish. Not sure why the flattening and sugar on top is needed? I just used a cookie scoop and baked.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Close
The Comfort of Cooking © Copyright 2020. All rights reserved.
Close